 |
|
 |
Early Iraqi death counts
|
|
"One has to be a lowbrow, a bit
of a murderer, to be a politician, ready and willing to see
people sacrificed, slaughtered, for the sake of an idea, whether
a good one or a bad one."
(Henry Miller)
One of the PR "advantages" for governments which
instigate war is that death counts are virtually impossible
in the early days. This allows military/political PR to claim
minimum "collateral damage" as the war is being
fought, with little evidence available for the media to refute
it (assuming they're inclined to do so). Thus, for example,
rightwing historian Andrew Roberts described the Iraq war
as "brilliant" not long after the initial invasion.
Eventually, however, news of a growing mass slaughter emerged,
despite the apparent reluctance of many news organisations
to focus on it:
Iraqi doctor, Osama Saleh al-Duleimi, a witness to
two previous wars, commented on the situation in Iraq, April
2003: "I've been a doctor for 25 years and this is the
worst I've seen in terms of casualty numbers and fatal wounds."
(The Independent 7/4/03)
As the US prepared to attack Baghdad, the Pentagon
reported that the 80,000-strong Iraqi Republican Guard outside
the city had been "degraded" or rendered "ineffective"
by bombardment. Analysts estimated at least 10,000 deaths,
probably much more. (Associated Press 8/4/03)
By mid-April 2003, Iraq Body Count (one of
the very few groups analysing Iraqi deaths at this time) had
already recorded/corroborated over 1,000 Iraqi civilians as
reported killed in the war (http://www.iraqbodycount.org).
From The Independent, 19/5/03: A tally of Baghdad
hospital records published yesterday suggested that at least
1,700 civilians died in the Iraqi capital during the US invasion
and another 8,000 were injured [...] As many as 1,000 people
are still missing, according to Islamic burial societies and
humanitarian groups.
By June 2003, Iraq Body Count gave a figure of 10,000
Iraqi civilian deaths based on corroborated media reports.
(The Guardian, 13/6/2003)
In November 2003, Medact (an organisation of
health professionals) quoted the figure of 55,000 dead as
a direct result of the Iraq war. Their number is based on
several sources, including the media-reported civilian death
count from Iraq Body Count and press reports of Iraqi armed
forces deaths.
They also mention the psychological aftermath of war creating
"enormous anxiety" and leading to increases in mental
disorders, suicide, drug/alcohol abuse and social/domestic
violence. (Associated Press, 12/11/03)
http://www.smh.com.au/articles/2003/11/12/1068329606778.html
For more detail on later death counts, see our body
counts section (not yet available
coming soon).
Injured counts
The total number of injured Iraqis was unknown in the early
days of hostilities (and is still largely unknown). A possible
guideline can be deduced from various sources eg the
Iraqi Ministry of Health reported
2.9 wounded for each person killed in the period from
mid-2004 to mid-2006. An almost identical ratio was given
in an analysis
by Iraq Body Count of media-derived data for the first
two years after the invasion.
It was reported in September 2003 that more than 6,000 American
servicemen had been evacuated from Iraq for medical reasons
since the beginning of the war, including more than 1,500
American soldiers who had been wounded, many seriously. (Observer,
14/9/03)
|